Movie #2142 "Where the Crawdads Sing" (movie theatre) I loved this book and have recommended it to many, and I am here to say that I loved the movie, as well, even though the critics have not been kind to it. Yep, Audiences are giving the rotten tomatoes score of 97% to the film, and the critics, a mere 36%. Rarely, very very rarely is there such separation. And when there is some separation, I usually look through the critiques and nod my head and say to myself, I can see what they didn't like ....but~! I have looked through the "Crawdads" comments over and over, and they seem unwarranted. And the meanest to me are by females! what is that all about????? The first thing you can tell by watching the opening credits is that this is a female-run film --- even the director of photography and the editor are both females. I wonder how much that has happened, if at all. There are a few men's names sprinkled in (one I noticed was a producer), but this is by and large a female -run film, with a female director at the helm. That being said, I felt so proud watching all the beautiful images that crossed the screen --- the story well told, even dealing with a huge change from the novel --- the lack of the voice of Kya, telling the story herself, her narration on every page. It comes in and out , for sure, but she isn't constantly in our ears, and she is a very quiet person. (played very well by Daisy Egan-Jones, whom I last saw as a completely different person in "Normal People" - another show I highly recommend). So we depend on every look , every turn of the head, every eye movement.....very detailed. Well thought out. We are Inside her without that narration. Yes, there are changes in the structure of the book and where the flashbacks go -- I couldn't remember all of them, but I remember an edit in the film where we are watching her footprints in the sand and it moves swiftly to the trial about no footprints there. Wow! And there's another edit that goes from a young couple to an old one to show passage of time that is just glorious! Photography is stunning. And what did one (female) critic say? She complained that she didn't see any crawdads..... another one said:"you never feel Kya's connection to her environment" --- huh? image after image is shown with her traveling in her boat with her hand in the water, or sitting lazily in the boat reading, or sitting on the shore looking at the birds --- and all the pictures she has drawn in her home of nature --- Another critic said "run of the mill drama" --- really? does every run of the mill drama have such rich characters as the black family that helps her out, a totally abusive family that abandons her? a bullied, picked on "marsh girl" accused of murder? a great turn of events ending? Another one says "Poor pacing" --- there's a huge variety of pacing --- have these people sat through "Lord of the Rings"? did they accuse that film of poor pacing because I would have..... "Lack of character depth" -- I can honestly say I don't remember ever seeing a movie character so shy and quiet, full of such richness and depth of character. "An all-white reboot of To Kill Mockingbird"? mean!" This 125 minute film seems longer than that!" Well, there's a critic who missed the boat! "This kind of lifeless, misguided adaptation that makes you wonder what anyone saw in the book in the first place" --- Wow! There are more, but my point is that these critics aren't always correct when judging a film (oftentimes I feel that way about how they judge comedies and rom-coms, my favorite genre) , and I think they are wrong with this film. I'm not sure why they would pick on this one.....(although I can make some guesses - some didn't read the book in the first place, don't usually like adaptations of well thought of books, one critic hints that she is leery of all popular books anyway, and possibly, dare I say, they don't like the movie because they discount it as a chick film?) So I guess I'm here to say : don't let the critics keep you away from this film, and if you like it, continue to spread the word that this film is a good one and should be seen and supported by us. Thanks for reading through my whining..............I give this 5 out of 5. Take that, you mean critics!
"WHERE THE CRAWDADS SING" 2022 2 hours and 5 minutes PG-13
Director: Olivia Newman
Writers: Delia Owens, Lucy Alibar
Stars: Daisy Edgar-Jones, David Strathairn